Studio Ponoc (heir to Studio Ghibli) has adapted Mary Stewart’s 1971 children’s book The Little Broomstick as its debut animated feature, with the title Mary and the Witch’s Flower, and ever since I found out about this in December 2016 I have been desperate to see it. On Tuesday evening, ahead of the UK release date of 4 May, there were advance screenings of the film in Japanese with English subtitles. Reader, I watched it. And loved it, and will certainly watch it again.
I saw Mary and the Witch’s Flower in the Cameo Cinema in Edinburgh. We were in Screen 2 and even although the event was sold out the room cannot hold more than about fifty people, so it was an intimate experience where you get a good idea of how others are reacting to the film too. I didn’t think to take a photo of the room but I spotted a tweet by @LesaLionHeart and she has kindly agreed to let me share her photo:

The Cameo provided goodies in the form of a poster and a sheet summarising the background to the film and film studio.

The Little Broomstick was named on the sheet but Mary Stewart herself was not. This was repeated in the ‘featurette’ that preceeded the film, where she was ‘the author’ rather than named, but she was of course named in the film credits. I found the featurette really interesting: members of the Ponoc team explained the meaning of Ponoc, how they scout locations rather than simply draw from photos, and I was pleased to hear that they wanted to honour the author’s obvious love and respect for nature.
Then the film began! Visually it is stunning, being beautifully drawn, colourful, highly imaginative and dynamic. I was hooked, both by the look of the film and by the story. There are of course differences between book and film but I felt that Mary and the Witch’s Flower stayed true to the spirit of the book. A central theme in all Mary Stewart novels is an examination of how ‘ordinary’ people react to wrong-doing and face up to danger. The heroine here, Mary Smith, is the youngest in a line of Mary Stewart heroines standing up for what is right, despite being afraid.
Mary Stewart’s love of animals shines through in her novels and nowhere more than in The Little Broomstick. The film version even adds to this with a short sequence where Mary follows Tib the cat not so much because she is bored and lonely but because he seems to be mysteriously changing colour from black to grey. The audience in Screen 2 greeted the solution to this mystery with a breath of laughter, showing how nicely this scene worked. There was more laughter when Mary spoke to her Great-Aunt Charlotte’s dog and the audience learned his name – I am sure this reaction would have pleased Mary Stewart immensely. Some suspenseful moments in the film caused many in the audience to gasp involuntarily, a sure sign that we were gripped by the narrative.
Very briefly, the narrative is one where Mary Smith follows a cat who leads her to a rare purple flower with magical powers. By sheer accident, she releases this power and a broomstick flies her off to Endor College, a place of unethical ‘science’ and witchcraft, where she meets Madam Mumblechook and Doctor Dee, and discovers sinister goings-on: ‘trespassers will be transformed’ is a rule followed with gusto at this school of witchcraft. Animals – and in the film a friend too – are in danger: how can Mary save them?
The film, then, has very suspenseful moments, just like Mary Stewart’s writing. And there is a quiet beauty to the film’s portrayal of the Shropshire countryside with its riots of flowers and fields of sheep, that also reflects Mary Stewart’s love of natural history and ability to write vivid setting. And one last detail that I loved – I was pleased to spot a tub of Celebrations in Great-Aunt Charlotte’s kitchen: you can read about how Ponoc Studio studied English life during their visit to Shropshire, leading them to include these chocolates in the film, in this Shropshire Star article. Both in its detail and in its scope, this film was highly enjoyable and I am looking forward to seeing it again in May, and to seeing the reactions of my children and my god-daughter.

It sounds wonderful! You’re so lucky to have been able to see it already. 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks, Rosetta, I am fortunate to have seen this film and, whether on DVD or the big screen, I recommend it to you, I think you’ll enjoy it!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’m sure I will. As soon as I get the chance! 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Just rewatched the film as will be interviewing the director very soon, and was looking around for other people’s thoughts to help think out my questions — and I’m so glad someone else spotted the Celebrations tin! Thought it was such a lovely touch that very few would spot, let alone understand. Great review, and thank you for your article on the book, it was very helpful!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hi, thanks for your comments! It must be wonderful to get to interview the director of this film – personally, I’d love some detail as to just how he discovered The Little Broomstick. And yes, I also felt that the Celebrations chocolates were a lovely detail – a piece of homely realism juxtaposed by the high fantasy of the world of magic. A lovely film.
Have you written a review of Mary and the Witch’s Flower already, and when will your upcoming interview be published? I’d love to read your thoughts.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Ah! Well I actually know the answer to that! The director is a big fan of English fantasy literature, as can be seen by the fact his first two films are also English fantasy (and by female writers!) but it was actually the producer Nishimura that discovered the book. They were reading through many books of a similar period specifically in search of a subject to adapt, but they chose The Little Broomstick after the line about Mary wanting to open the door without magic regardless of how long it takes, as they found it was very relevant to their current situation involving leaving the “magic” of studio Ghibli. They were drawn to a character that chooses to face the end on their own, rather than rely on magic, as is usually the case. Hope this answered your question! These are all things I picked up from research, but they delve into a few more things in the interview (although I would have loved more time of course!)
Interview goes up in a week and a bit to coincide with the full UK cinema release, and the review will go up alongside most likely. Have to admit it won’t be a fully glowing review, however that is more down to the filmmaking itself and the industry context behind it, as opposed to the source material!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks for sharing this insight, that is fascinating! I love that bit, how 10 year old Mary can figure out the fairness/ethics of when and how to use magic but Madam Mumblechook and Doctor Dee with their ‘scientific’ witchcraft are blind to ethics.
I’m really looking forward to your interview and review!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I have yet to see the film, but this discussion reminds me of a quote from a much more commercial movie that I just saw for the first time. The quote:
“That’s how we’re gonna win. Not fighting what we hate, saving what we love,”
LikeLiked by 1 person
Is that Star Wars, Jerri? You’re right, that emphasis sounds about right for Mary and the Witch’s Flower too!
LikeLike
Hi Allison, I’d love to see this film now and am wondering if my youngest daughter, who is nine, will enjoy it or whether she will feel a little old for it. The rating is a U and the animation style looks quite childish (in the literal sense) in the posters, but Mary Stewart’s stories don’t usually patronise readers. Having seen it, what do you think? (I still haven’t read the book yet so can’t go by that.) Annabel
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’m sure that the Cameo marketed the film as a PG but I have also seen it marked U so I’m not too sure what the final certificate is… I have also seen it rated by Common Sense as age 8+ here: https://www.commonsensemedia.org/movie-reviews/mary-and-the-witchs-flower I’d hope that your daughter would love it! It does have some mildly scary/sinister scenes. And it kept this adult completely entertained! Many fans of anime are adults. I hope this helps
LikeLike